I recently came across a documentary called “Look and See”. It is about the life and works of Wendell Berry and is produced by Robert Redford. There is so much about this film that I love. The trailer captures the rawness of the First Half and Second Half of life. There is a clear break / split between the two…that is worth spending two minutes to watch. The last scene says its is all without having to use words about what life becomes living in the Second Half of life.
The dawn has settled in and we are now resting in the light of the day. “I am connected” becomes more of the norm. Were we not connected before? Yes, of course, but the connection was not felt most of the time because we were asleep. Our ego (smaller self) kept us from being awake. When one moves into Stage Eight, you are now awake and able to see. We are home and our home resides in us! We can see out of the “third eye” as some would say. It is a new way of viewing and living in the world. We can trust that we are living fully in ourSelf. Therefore, we no longer seek many answers outside us because the answer is in us. The thing, person, possession we have been looking for is Us! We are now connected to ourself, to others, to partner, and to God. We come to realize that we have always had this Knowing and Connectedness but just didn’t know to trust it because our smaller self kept getting in the way. But now, it is different. This does not mean we no longer need others wisdom. We continue to share our shortcomings and struggles. The purpose has changed and it is to not be fixed. Rather it is to be known and to have a shared experience with another. It is no longer about ourself. We are able to love fully because we have the ability to look and see and be. Our will doesn’t keep us separate from our community of others. The autonomous “smaller self” does not keep us fractured from the environment, culture, community, and family. We have and are living out the capacity of love because we are no longer a slave to our self, our work, our high paying profession, our ego!
It is at this place that we are able to share troubling aspects of ourSelf and see these aspects as a part of us but not all of ourSelf. We are now able to say “yep, that’s a part of me” with truth and honesty yet without the shame and guilt that plagued us so much in our earlier years of life.
In this stage, we have entered the ultimate boon as Joseph Campbell calls it. The ultimately boon is often realized when the major conflict of our story is resolved. We have made atonement (at-one-ment) with ourSelf. We are able to do this because our hearts are completely open for loving out of our True Self. We are no longer plagued by our limitations of our first half of life. Though we certainly still make mistakes. But life feels more like the state of flow as athletes describe it. We are able accept life as it is and realize that everything is as it should be. It is accepting the impermanence (every changing aspects) of life. Can we do it all the time? No, but we can begin living in such a way that the things that are not right in our (smaller) world become ok because it is just not ours to fight anymore. We are now living with eyes for a (Larger) world. We become more and more able to live out that beautiful serenity prayer… “God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference”. - Richard Niebuhr.
In our journey, what we come to learn and trust is our experience and that experience comes from within. God is no longer out there but within us. Our experience has taught us to trust that everything we need is within us. Our outside attachments no longer hinder us from sitting with ourSelf. We experience it in relationships and love. This connection cannot be fully explained nor is it ever meant to be explained. This connection can only be pointed to and described as peace. Rilke in the Book of Hours says it this way,
“I live my life in widening circles
that reach out across the world.
I may not complete this last one
but I give myself to it."
Side note, our whole idea of God has shifted and changed. It is not the same god we believed in from our childhood. This doesn’t mean we reject our faith of old. It just means our connectedness has expanded to something much bigger than what we learned. This God can’t be confined to some denomination, sect, religion, or theology. In fact, we have realized we can’t really put to words or describe what God “is”. The moment we try to talk “about god” we have already limited and made certain constructs and limited this Higher Power.
The rest of our life is about giving of ourSelf now that we are fully Connected. The watermark is that we have ourSelf to give. We are no longer giving out of nothing. In the first half of life, we were trying to give and die to ourSelf but we were giving out of our(smaller)self. Therefore, we felt more empty and despair than life. Now, things are no longer black and while, gain and loss. “Everything belongs” as Rohr says.
We are moving into the last Stage which is rest and being exactly the way we were originally intended to be…”I am Me”. We are fully living out of our essence. It becomes our life’s mission, but without the ego in charge. Therefore, power and control are not our driving subconscious forces. We are living fully as a vessel.
There is something that has changed and it comes upon us by surprise and without effort. Finally, a reprieve...but why? Generally, the circumstances are no different and nothing on the outside is different but something is different! It is much like a breath of fresh air or a fresh aroma that is new yet so familiar. The familiarity is of something old and ancient. The aroma, so to speak, reminds us of something yet we can't quite put our finger on it. It may be the aroma (i.e. feeling) you felt when you arrived at your grandmothers or the comfort of a nurturing figure you had so long ago. It is of something distant yet close at the same time.
Something new has happened because we shift from future opportunities to realizing and living out the truth that there are only opportunities for this moment. Pain and suffering become less of the focus because our relationship to suffering has changed. We begin to sense an inkling that we are tapped into something much bigger. It feels very mysterious yet core. Most of all, we are learning to sit in the emptiness. Yet the difference is we are able to sit long enough for the unfolding. It happens without our self-will.
And if something doesn't unfold -- we are able to wait and are ok with the waiting. It is in the waiting that events occur that were not thought or planned. It is less about the controlling, achieving, willing, or performing one's way through it and instead...we are able to see a need, ask, wait, trust, let go, and then respond. Note: This is not meant to be a formula. In fact, there are no formulas, thought processes, paradigms, or systems. Those all point to the smaller self. Those are the things we try to formalize, trademark, whereby it becomes more about us and following a known and controllable system. This is what the ego wants! There is something much larger / mysterious leading and cannot be quantified because it is something Other. We come to know by experience that this Other is found within us not outside us. This is the beginning of contemplation. We are learning to be connected through contemplation which will be discussed in Stage 8.
In reflecting over my practice, some of the most powerful therapy sessions I have been apart of came when utilizing Brainspotting or EMDR. These therapies sound complex but are essentially are very simple. In a lot of ways, its like hyper-focused mindfulness. It is not that these are the answer or some formula. Otherwise, clients would experience healing 100% of the time. Yet, when these do work, clients report clarity and peace (ah ha moments) where they come to some realization on their own - a message from within. I have seen it time and time again and it is always much more powerful and transformative than something I provide. I say all this because it affirms that we already hold the answer from within.
We come to sit in the empty space knowing and trusting that this is where life is lived. We begin to know by experience that something much deeper inside will lead us. We come to experience that we have never been as alone as we thought. That in fact something was with us all this time. Up till now, we have been trying to gain by improvement but we learned to let go in Stage 6 which is what opened up newness. David Whyte states that "to be yourself requires a radical initiation or simplification".
Derek Walcott's poem Love after Love "
The time will come
when, with elation,
you will greet yourself arriving
at your own door, in your own mirror,
and each will smile at the other’s welcome,
and say, sit here. Eat.
You will love again the stranger who was your self.
Give wine. Give bread. Give back your heart
to itself, to the stranger who has loved you
all your life, whom you ignored
for another, who knows you by heart.
Take down the love letters from the bookshelf,
the photographs, the desperate notes,
peel your own image from the mirror.
Sit. Feast on your life.
Entering into this stage...let's just say it is usually done by crawling and crying...until we finally stop and learn to sit. Just when you thought the pain and humiliation would stop it doesn't. But why? What is the point to all this raw pain and suffering? It is here in this Stage that we learn to accept and acknowledge our powerlessness. In Stage 5, we are faced with our immense shadow and / or our brokenness. Finally we are learning to fully let go. We come to accept and live with this feeling of powerlessness. This feeling comes from our Smaller Self, also known as our ego. As Richard Rohr states regarding this stage, "Almost any attempt to save yourself by any superior behavior, technique, belonging system, morality, role, strong ideological belief, or religious devotion will not work....that some event, struggle, relationship, or suffering in your life has to lead you to the edge of your own resources." Little did we realize till now that all our religious performing, meditation techniques, self help plans, academic knowledge and even should I dare say "Biblical knowledge" does not work. It is not that those things in and of themselves are the problem. The problem was that our Smaller Self was in charge. We were living out of self will.
This may sound crazy but we are learning to have a relationship with darkness or emptiness. Rohr explains, "darkness is a much better teacher than supposed certainty or rightness" or light. David Whyte shared, in his audiobook Midlife and the Great Unknown, that so much of the journey is embracing the unknown. Whyte states, "We learn to have a relationship with the unknown [powerlessness] that all the work in reality has been done. Now we must learn to just let go...Me, myself I will throw away...to be humiliated means to return to the ground of being". Suffering comes from all the things and attachments we were trying to hold onto that were just not ours to hold in the first place. Rohr states that "suffering is optional pain is not". Pain are those tragedies and events where life interrupts and rips aways things we held dear. Suffering is the unnecessary longings we mistakenly take as satisfying. There is a phrase in 12-step communities that we stop trying to force solutions. And instead we learn to wait. We begin to befriend the pain and suffering. During this stage, it will feel less like a friend and more like a distant acquaintance. But that experience will soon change in Stage 7.
The point to all this is that we are learning to let go, so that something in us and through us can lead. It is similar to what happens to seeds before they germinate. The seeds are buried in the ground in complete and total darkness so that something can grow out of the soil into something new. The same is true with us but we cannot skip this process otherwise we are back to living out of the smaller self. Words cannot adequately describe this state of being. It is filled with contradictions of both death and hope, pain and optimism, waiting and longing, anxiousness and peace, addiction and grace, betrayal and love, and so on. The great paradox is that our first half of life is dying off and we are in many ways returning to a womb of darkness so that we can experience a birth of transformation. John O'Donohue gave a beautiful discussion in his audio lecture series "The Inner Landscape" where he speaks at length regarding suffering. John stated, "Wounds aren't sent to make you small, they are sent to you to open you up to make you more kind, gracious, and beautiful....Real suffering is where the contractions within us harmonize." It is not smallness we are after. We all want to expand but to expand is so painful that is why so few if ever choose such a path. The beauty is that the path, in many ways, chooses us if we will honor and stay true to the journey. David Whyte so poetically wrote, "the antidote to exhaustion is not necessarily rest...the antidote to exhaustion is wholeheartedness". This is what is happening and allowing us to move to Stage 7. It is an expansion of heart which allows us to move to Stage 7: I am my(larger)self.
There is a beautiful poem by Christine Lore Weber called Mother Wisdom Speaks that encapsulates this stage in life.
Mother Wisdom Speaks
Some of you I will hollow out.
I will make you a cave.
I will carve you so deep the stars will shine in your darkness.
You will be a bowl.
You will be the cup in the rock collecting rain.
I will hollow you with knives.
I will not do this to make you clean.
I will not do this to make you pure
You are clean already.
You are pure already.
I will do this because the world needs the hollowness of you.
I will do this for the space that you will be.
I will do this because you must be large.
People will find their way through you.
People will eat from you.
And their hunger will not weaken them to death.
A cup to catch the sacred rain.
My daughter [son], do not cry.
Do not be afraid.
Nothing you need will be lost.
I am shaping you.
I am making you ready.
Light will flow in your hollowing.
You will be filled with light.
Your bones will shine.
The round open center of you will be radiant.
I will call you brilliant one.
I will call you daughter [son] who is wide.
I will call you transformed.
Here we completely identify with our wounds and can't see past them. This is a time in life where life has completely fallen apart, a time so painful that you just want it to stop. What makes this pain worse is that our shame / shadow self compounds the pain because of negative beliefs / scripts we believe during this stage in life. But if we have people loving on us, believing in us, carrying hope for us, we can ultimately experience our wounds differently.
It is during this stage that we must face our wounds and shame. We have to begin to address / name them because if we don't, we will not progress. Our shame can be understood as negative beliefs we have picked up along the way that are specific to our own story and experiences. These shame scripts can look like the following: I'm bad, I'm too much, I'm a failure, I'm permanently damaged, I'm not lovable, I'm not good enough, I don't belong, and I should have done something.
But the wound is our doorway...or really a trap door where we ultimately fall down into the next stage. This is the time in our lives, if we can allow ourself (smaller self) to get out of the way, that real transformation begins to take place. This has to happen below the surface, in ways we do not understand nor see. If we could see what was happening, we would try to block / run from it entirely or change it to fit our limited viewpoint. Gerald May in his book Dark Night of the Soul highlights a saying from Saint John of the Cross which states "God has to work in the soul in secret and in darkness, because if we fully knew what was happening, and what Mystery/transformation/God/grace will eventually ask of us, we would either try to take charge or stop the whole process.
To move forward and out of this stage will require two things. First, we have to see and name our shadow self. Secondly, and this goes against our nature, we have to be loved by others and stop our own striving. We need others holding up the loving light that we only see partially, from a our viewpoint of shame, because of our distorted view. Our shame seems real and is real to us, but it is not Real. We must have others loving on us in a way that is no longer performance based. What we need is to be loved for who we are, not what we do, nor what we think.
It is from these few people that we get to feel the Radical love of God. It usually comes from only a few people throughout our life. For me personally, I can count on one hand these individuals that loved me in such a profound way that you feel loves lasting impression. It feels both embarrassing and comforting at the same time. For they see all of you and what it is that you are becoming. They actually see you and call forth the truths that are within you, like seeds in the beginning stages of germination. I remember a moment a few years ago that so marks this stage. It was while sitting with my own therapist...that all I could do was look down and hold my hands over my eyes in an attempt to hide. Then this dear person looks at me so graciously and tells me she sees me and that what she sees is something opposite of my shame scripts. What she saw was the real and authentic me and I realized I was ok just as I am. This "seeing" was the beginning a new experience and new version to an old story.
In Robert Bly's wonderful book Iron John he describes this experience by the following...
"I think we can regard therapy, when it is good, as a waiting by the pond. Each time we dip our wound into that water, we get nourishment, and the strength to go on further in the process. Initiation, then, does not mean ascending above the wound, nor remaining numbly inside it; but the process lies in knowing how or when, in the presence of the mentor, to dip it in the water. The wound that hurts us so much we "involuntarily" dip it in water, we have to regard as a gift. How would the boy in our story have found out about his genius if he had not been wounded? Those with no wounds are the unluckiest of all. Our story...says that where a man's [woman's] wound is, that is where his [her] genius will be...that is precisely the place for which we will give our major gift to the community."
Life lived authentically, in the shadowlands, begins to open us to a something much bigger...a much Larger Self. A Self that has always resided in us. It is that ever still small voice that we begin to ever so faintly hear. It is that ever still small voice that we begin to hear louder and louder. It is one that we will so begin to trust but we must let go any remaining outside attachments. We must experience one last stage of dying before it takes place. We begin to start to accept our emptiness and powerlessness. But we will not able to fully accept until we enter and live in the next stage of "I am powerless" which will be discussed in the next blog.
I am my(smaller)self feels like we have arrived and are enlightened. This stage represents us reaching our full personality. This is us being healthy in the best way we know how. For the most part , we are "doing" a pretty good job at it. We are contributing to our society. And we are successful at what we are doing. And we are now able to distance ourselves from the some of the reactive emotions and legalistic norms most of us grew up experiencing. We have reconnected to our bodies.
The biggest indicator is that we have begun to be present to ourselves. Present to our emotions, thoughts and especially our bodies. To be present to our bodies may sound strange and yet it is vital that we come back to the awareness of it. This is why breathing through meditation is so important. It helps us reconnect to our body. In this Stage more than any prior one, we have come to an awareness of ourselves and our smaller self. If you know the Enneagram, this is your Enneagram number or ego state. The Enneagram is an ancient personality map believed to have been developed around 300 AD. I have found it as a helpful tool in seeing our smaller self . Our smaller self is not bad or wrong in and of itself. The problem is that it doesn't go far enough and is merely a projection of what we want others to see about us verses actually being fully seen. This "seeing" first has to come from us seeing ourselves. We begin to see we are the problem. That everything we are doing is really about and for ourself.
For me, this is the realization that I most identify as an Enneagram 3 which means I am the performer and achiever. This also is the number I dislike the most because it hits closest to home. As a performer and achiever, I can be success oriented and driven but also the charmer and salesperson. Another way to say it is that I struggle being authentic and direct. But at times I can't help it because it is my "go to" in navigating life. Every one of us developed our ego state from survival skills. Therefore, our Enneagram number is a useful way to see oneself in a holistic way that provides a map to become fully ourself. The challenge is that we want to remain and hide in our smaller self. We do this because its known and comfortable.
It will require a death to our ego to learn to reside outside our mask. Sometime in life, usually midlife, we are confronted that the way we are navigating life isn't working. It is this time in life where it feels like the wheels are about to fall off. This is when we have to confront our wounds that we have been running from, but if we honor our wounds, these wounds will turn to gold. It has been said that one of the best things to happen to a person is to experience and embrace that which we have been avoiding. As an Enneagram 3 type, the blessing came in my failure of life. We 3's absolutely avoid failure. We don't want to fail because we have tried so hard to build things / attachments around us to help us feel worth and significance. More than anything else in this stage, we have to be willing to accept the pain. A helpful tool is looking at our Enneagram number and seeing what it is we are really trying to avoid. Then instead of running from it we embrace it. But if you were like me, I resisted accepting failure so I hold on until I was completely broken. And for most, life usually takes us through it instead of us choosing it. Once we acknowledge our pain we then have to enter into more pain and live there which is the next stage...some call it The Dark Night of the Soul or My Shadow Self is Who I Am which will be discussed in the next Stage.
Below is the list of enneagram numbers and what each number avoids...
- 1 - The Reformer - avoids mistakes and being criticized
- 2 - The Helper - avoids disappointing others
- 3 - The Performer - avoids failure
- 4 - The Individualist - avoids being insignificant
- 5 - The Investigator - avoids being incapable
- 6 - The Loyalist - avoids being without support or guidance
- 7 - The Enthusiast - avoids pain or being ordinary
- 8 - The Protector - avoids being controlled or tricked by others
- 9 - The Peacemaker - avoids conflict
* other terms or meanings --- ego, provisional self, false self, shadow self
This stage "I am my feelings" feels like a drastic change from the prior stage. Emotions are the sole universal language. It spans across all cultures and societies. It is quite extraordinary when you think about it, so why do we not give much attention to our emotions? It stems from receiving negative signals / messages early on in life that it was not ok to feel and express our emotions (i.e. parented and taught from Stage 1 or 2 parents and society). Therefore, we slowly adapted to operate out of our heads instead of our hearts. We were born with an innate ability to feel and interpret others feelings. To grow into this stage, we must awaken to the language of emotions which can feel both thrilling and terrifying. Because to become aware of our emotions requires us to actually feel our emotions. It can be very intense at first to allow yourself to actually feel. Usually, it has been so long since we opened ourselves to our emotional world that we at first feel off center or overly dramatic. The other layer is then sharing what you feel with others. This is where the rubber meets the road. It puts words to senses / feelings we didn't quite know how to name. If we didn't grow up using the language of emotions, we would not know it is ok and healthy to say "I am sad" or "I feel hurt". This is usually where our attachment styles begin to show up and interfere with emotional connection. A marker of a dysfunctional relationship is not being able to freely share your emotions nor being able to hear / receive what another feels.
Friel and Friel wrote a great deal on the language of emotions in the 1980's. In their book Adult Children, they wrote that our most core emotions are hurt, angry, sad, fear, shame, guilt, lonely, and glad. These emotions are neither good nor bad but just indicators that act as a compass. The reason we initially think all are negative except glad is that we have been unable to distinguish the emotions to the negative reactions we have associated to them. Anger is not violence. But anger can invoke violence. But if the family and / or society did not teach that anger does not equal violence then we will naturally confuse the two. We cannot control our emotions but we can learn to regulate them. The more we learn to live and honor our emotions, the more we can respond instead of react. Honoring our feelings is not the same as "doing what we feel like doing". We feel so we can be grounded. It is one thing to know our feelings and it is entirely different to experience them. This is the crux of what separates those in Stage 3 from Stage 2. Those who begin to allow themselves room to feel their feelings begin to grow in the capacity to sit in their emotions. Emotions provide us with the energy to live and the gift to grieve. Robert Bly said grief is the privileged emotion or the unfinished hurt. By not feeling our emotions, it keeps us from being in touch what we what we are feeling, with who we are, and what motivates us.
The gift of emotions is that it allows us to be seen and known. Emotion in Latin means "to move" so its the musical notes to the dance of the relationship. It invites us to connect with ourselves so we can then connect with another. Emotions are a gateway to our soul in that it exposes our needs and vulnerabilities. The gift of showing and expressing them is that it allows others to see you and then connect with you. Tim Keller provides a powerful quote and paradigm as follows:
“To be loved but not known is comforting but superficial. To be known and not loved is our greatest fear. But to be fully known and truly loved is, well, a lot like being loved by God.
We see this Stage visibly in the politics of our country. This Stage tends to look like the left leaning democratic party verses right leaning in Stage 2. They tend to be more concerned with other's rights and not just their own. Ideally, one that is connected to emotions would then show more empathy but often we hide behind the emotions instead of truly feeling them. Whereby we are prone to just use the words. We saw this recently at the White House correspondence dinner where a left leaning comedian roasted someone on the right side of the political isle. The reality is that all the fighting between the two sides are still pretty immature and mean. The political parties in itself are not the problem. The problem is our interaction in the political discourse and our inability as a society to hold together two opposing views and all the while still have love and compassion for our brothers and sisters. But, this Stage does carry one aspect that helps it be a little more evolved. The gift it brings is social justice and the ability to begin caring for others outside of one's owns tribe.
But the shortfall of this Stage can be summed up by the phrase "I feel therefore I am". Our emotions do not equal enlightenment. If anything, it predisposes us to be to self-focused and causes us to do a lot of naval gazing. There is a great risk in being controlled by our feeling world because it causes us to be over-reliant on our emotions. The reality is that there is no way around this. We will have our emotions but will hide behind them for our benefit. This will not change until we fully experience them and learn to not be controlled by them. I liken this to what Rohr calls "breathing under water". Initially we discover the language of emotions and are perfectly content to live by the beach and even swim in the ocean. It is not until pain and tragedy pulls us under water do we finally realize that we can breath under water. But with it comes with immense fear which will be discussed in Stage 5 and Stage 6. There is a beautiful except from Richard Rohr's daily mediations* that I want to share regarding emotions.
Bill Wilson saw the Twelve Steps finally leading to emotional sobriety. Sobriety is not just about no longer drinking. The goal is to become spiritually awakened, to have found some degree of detachment from our own emotions. Our emotions are not bad until and unless we are attached to them; they are helpful indicators and symptoms of what's going on, often subconsciously, within us. However, emotions are primarily "narcissistic reactions." They're self-referential because they are actually based in our body, not easily available to conscious control. The body carries all of our shame, guilt, childhood conditioning, and past hurts.
If we allow it, life begins to ask us to loosen our grip on our life and begin to surrender to those things we want and feel. We learn to become more connected to our bodies and our smaller self to be discussed in the next Stage. This is the necessary step to take in order to evolve and mature by learning how to sit in our emotions without letting our emotions be "the thing" leading us. This requires the ability to sit and suffer in the associated experiences by having these emotions. We begin to see in the next step that while emotions are great and helpful, they are more about us and not another. We begin to be able to see our emotions for what they really are and what they are not. They are not our be all end all. We begin to find more meaning outside our emotional world. We begin to see that our emotions are not the language of our heart, something much deeper is...that Another (i.e. Voice of God) is!
*Except from Rohr's Daily Mediations dated June 6, 2016
"You may drive out nature with a pitchfork, yet she'll be constantly running back." - Horace
Stage 2: "I am my tribe / I am my behavior" is the time in our lives where we find much of our identity from a group. This is the most natural place to land in life. To arrive here, it requires believing, agreeing, and behaving according to the group, church, and community you want to join. Richard Rohr observes that the majority of the world's population resides in Stage 2. This is when one navigates life through the lens of black and white thinking. It is dualistic thinking whereby you are "with me or against me" and "either / or" thinking. It is also a time where one begins to gain identity from those behaviors. It may sound legalistic and it is, while strangely necessary. We just don't want to stay and live there.
The beauty and gift of this stage is that you learn to grow up some and follow rules and order. We need this early on in life. If not, we tend to struggle with addictions of every sort. That is why its necessary when we struggle with addiction of any sort to first focus on behavior and community. The problem is we just don't need to keep living in this stage.
It is our nature to be and stay in our tribe. You see this happening every Sunday. The Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., once said "it is appalling that the most segregated hour of Christian America is eleven o'clock on Sunday morning." We must evolve in order to get out of that way of living. Otherwise we will remain in this stage most of our lives. Jonah Goldberg the senior editor of National Review in his newly released book "Suicide of the West: How the Rebirth of Tribalism, Populism, Nationalism, and Identity Politics is Destroying American Democracy" speaks directly to this. His premise is that never before until the 1800's have we evolved into a society as quickly and rapidly as we have in the last 250 years. In fact, it was a miracle that we were able to evolve into a democratic capitalistic society. The problem is that we are not aware of how precious and precarious our society really is and if we fall back into tribal thinking we lose any sense of democracy. As a result, our virtues become our vices. Thus, we become an oppressive society. Civilization is simply the story a society tells itself about itself. Whereby, when we are apart of a group and we only see life from that group lens we tend to have a very black and white viewpoint of either you are in or you are out. Or we become very focused on protecting our group only.
As a result, this stage ends up being reactionary and creates cultural wars. But the end result and goal is not a "us / against them" mentality. "They" are not the problem, nor do "they" need to be fixed or controlled. That way only leads to more power. The goal is ascending above the black and white thinking. It is in finding a new way or view life from a third perspective. For true lasting change, the ego has to die (individually or as a society) for this to occur and will be discussed more in Stage 5, 6, and 7. The problem is we are numb to ourselves and stay in a denial of ourselves by focusing on our behavior, turning away from ourselves due to our wounds incurred in Stage 1. We end up living out of the compass of who others tell us to be. It is life lived as a human doing not a human being.
The most extreme result of this stage is the tribal fundamentalism of any religion, sect, or group. You see this in religion whether it be islamic fundamentalists or far-right wing evangelicalism. Generally, the motivating factors in these groups are power and fear and trying not to lose something. On an individual level, people are generally living out of the thinking / rational brain. They are living out of their head and are not connected to their emotions or bodies. This predisposes people to be more narcissistic and self-centered, leaving little room for empathy and compassion. The way out of this is reconnecting ourselves to emotion and compassion.
I fell into this stage from my freshman year of college till about 30. It was the time in my life when I focused on my behavior and trying to "be a good Christian". Prior to college, it certainly was all about me and all about being seen as cool and popular. But then I entered college and fortunately came across newly formed friends that were more focused on their spiritual beliefs and faith than they were just on themselves. At the time, it was a crisis of faith because I was trying to reconcile my life with my beliefs. In so many ways, I am thankful for that period of my life because it helped me form a stronger belief system. And it kept me from running wild. Back then, I knew that it was "grace" that saved me but honestly it was still about being good. I just learned to mask it. In reflection, I lived with the belief that if I could behave and live as my group lived the more I could be affirmed and liked. Unfortunately, the two unspoken requirements into the group (as with most) were beliefs and behaviors. If you did those well, you rose in esteem and good will within the group. That continued for me till my early 30s. What I inevitably did was perform, which ultimately caused me to lose and not live out of an authentic self. Instead, my compass was oriented in being appropriate and good instead of authentic and human. Fortunately, I was shown that I had to connect to my emotions and feelings. I remember when I first came across emotional language such as sad, angry, shame, hurt, etc. that it felt like I found a new language. I discovered that using the language of emotions allowed me to become more authentic and invited more emotional intimacy with others. It was the language of emotions that helped me move to Stage 3.
Ultimately, we must move out of our thinking / rational mind in order to be connect more to our emotions. It is not that we abandon our thoughts but instead find a way to feel more helping us connect more.
This initial and first stage of the human journey can be known as "I Am About Me". It is familiar to all of us because we have been there and we often go back. I am about me is the most basic and elementary stage of development and maturity or should I say immaturity. The fact of the matter is that it is also a necessary stage. The description of this stage has the continuum of a toddler to a teenager. It is typically from the age of birth to about 15 to 16. I think both ages still fit into the stage because both are still about oneself. They just use different mechanisms to try to negotiate what it is they want. Simply put, it is our screaming child and / or our angry adolescent. It is the toddler screaming on the floor of Target mad because they are not getting the toy they wanted. Or it is the adolescent on the iPhone taking selfies and posting with the hope of receiving a lot of likes.
These are age appropriate behaviors. The problem is when our age doesn't match our behavior...i.e. an adult raging by hitting walls or adults trying to relive their high school years. If one received consistent nurture, structure and security in the home, then they are usually able to move to the next stage. In this stage, it is vital one receives consistency and dependability. If we don't receive that loving support then we find that we are stuck in this stage going often to illegitimate ways to get these needs met. During our early years of development, it is important and good to have the space to be I am about me. But when we grow up too early, parts of our(selves) never get and receive the appropriate attention. The problem arises when we shift to over-thinking / over-functioning too early instead of having the space to "go about being about ourselves" whereby we eventually outgrow it. The results can lead to addiction, severe depression, psychosis, narcissism and other dysfunctional behaviors. It is due to not having the support needed to grow and move into the next stage. Also, a pattern begins to form and this fundamentally marks an ongoing struggle for the rest of our lives that we learn to undo in our latter years. It is the need and desire to change and control situations and emotions instead of honoring them. We begin to experience an emptiness / wounds that we desperately want to manage. Thus, our ego also known as our smaller or provisional self begins to form. The solution is that we need to receive love and understanding in this stage in order to begin giving love in the next stages. But when one didn't receive it (by ourselves and others), he or she goes to artificial means to get that love and keeps going back until the pain gets so intense that he / she hits a rock bottom. That is where they find themselves looking and needing behavior modification to help them get to the next stage which is about behavior / morality code.
All of us regress to this stage at various moments in our life even when we evolve and mature. I have found it to be helpful and more authentic to think of ourselves as various parts. It is through these various parts that some grow to become more assertive and managerial while other parts of us lag behind and remain wounded. This is where the idea of our inner child / children begins to make sense. Some of us grow up to become adult children where we learned to take on various survival skills such as over-responsibility or helpfulness all the while never receiving the attention one needed during those developmental years of life. Thereby, never fully being nurtured in all parts of oneself (i.e. inner children needing to grow up). As a result, these child like parts are abandoned and forgotten. It is out of these wounded parts that others have formed in order to protect our(selves). These protective parts/personas show up in the form of power, image, beauty and the like, all trying to receive, control love and attention in the way those parts know how. The problem is that it is not whole. It’s a split part therefore it will not fulfill or be whole. The healing has to go back to those wounded parts so there is no longer a need for the protective personas. But it is vital to know we could not have done it any other way. We had to utilize certain survival skills (over-responsibility, avoidance, dissociation, lying, workaholism, perfectionism, people pleasing) so we could navigate through our family, friendships and communities. This is also how we begin to see our our unique ego (or Enneagram number) beginning to develop which I will discuss in more detail in the following posts.
Rohr had called this stage I am about my body and recently referenced a quote I want to share. It was given in a different context but speaks beautifully to this stage.
"The body is a sacrament...a visible sign of invisible grace...All our inner life and intimacy of soul longs to find an outer mirror. It longs for a form in which it can be seen, felt, and touch. The body is the mirror where the secret world of the soul comes to expression. The body is a sacred threshold; and it deserves to be respected, minded, and understood in its spiritual nature...The body is the temple of the Holy Spirit. - John O'Donohue.
The point of all this is that we need and require others to help mirror what it is our soul is calling forth. We need help calling it forth. We fundamentally need compassion from others and for our(selves) so we can heal. Once we receive this...we can then move onto I am my behavior and I am my group.
As mentioned previously, I have reflected a great deal on the various stages in life. The whole point of writing on these stages is that we often don't know where we are, much less where we are headed. Usually, it does not even occur to us to think about our path until we have tripped up and injured ourselves or been injured...i.e. pain / life tragedies. This path is so long that we can't see the end of one stage because we are just trying to get around the next bend. As humans, we tend to want what we want when we want it and life just doesn't happen that way.
Life is not linear but often a series of ups and downs, backwards and forwards, or just stalled out in a stage of life. Some choose: to keep going, to keep fighting, and to keep growing. Others are stuck where they and are not able to grow. Moreover, some are asleep and numb to life because of the pain. Hence, there is goodness in suffering because its the pain that awakens us. I am reminded of something Rohr said that life is about order, disorder, then reorder. C.S. Lewis said it best: "But pain insists upon being attended to. God whispers to us in our pleasures, speaks in our conscience, but shouts in our pains: it is his megaphone to rouse a deaf world." And I might add a megaphone to our deaf world (ego / smaller self) we create for ourselves which is common to everyone one of us.
We find that our path is much less about pushing through it (at least it is this way until stage four) but that we find we are taken there, pushed there, or just fall into it. At the end, we realize that it is much less about us doing the work and more about the unfolding of life itself. I think our task is to stay awake to what is transpiring and to see the goodness and necessity of each stage. A musician friend shared a quote yesterday that encapsulates the hope of naming these stages. My hope is to name these stages without blaming (or at least not wave my finger as much)!
“To describe [the present age] is to challenge it. Isn’t that really what artists are supposed to do? It’s not their job to solve the problem. It’s their job to describe the problem. And part of the description is to realize that this is very attractive. And to admit one’s own attraction to it....so the job is to describe what’s going on, describe the attention, and be generous enough to not wave your finger at it as it’s going by.” - Bono
It is important to note...especially in our culture of achievement that the goal is not transforming into some exceptional person (as strange as that may sound) for life is more about subtraction than it is about addition. Instead, it is in coming back to who we have always been by having our false self fall off. For in the end, the most transformative and self-actualizing arrival is becoming fully human. It's in our full humanity that glory of God gets to be most on display!
It has been a while since I have posted...but hope to get back to consistently writing down the things along the way that I come across that are helpful as well as the things I'm learning personally. I plan on writing a series of blog posts all around this idea of specific stages in our journey. Much of this material comes from Ken Wilber's and Richard Rohr work. The impetus of this series was inspired by an email series Richard Rohr posted several years ago called "Evolution of Consciousness". There has not been a week that has gone by that I haven't reflected on his work around this concept.
The reason behind knowing these stages is that it provides some markers about where each of us might be in our journey of development as well as a map of where we are going. I have found that without it...there is a real sense of being lost.
- I am about me
- I am my tribe / I am my behavior
- I am my feelings / "I feel therefore I am"
- I am my(smaller)self
- I am my shame
- I am powerless
- I am my(Larger)self
- I am Connected (to myself, to God, to others, to intimate partner)
- I am me!
These are here to be more of a helpful resource to name our current experience. They are not steps to be achieved. Rather, they are mile markers helping name the maturing in life through experience. If we can learn, accept, and let go of the coping mechanisms / survivals skills of each stage, we slowly begin to evolve to the next stage. All of us - get a taste of more evolved stages here and there. Think of a moment where it was like heaven on earth and it felt like you transcended time. That likely could have been a moment of Stage 9.
What this is not...this is not a prescription for every person...each person has to open himself/herself to the unique mystery within. It is not us against them or better / worse mentality. Every person is equal of love and mercy. Thomas Merton made a bold statement regarding this saying, "The man who lives in division lives in death". This is not to be a prescription to set us apart or to become more of a spiritual type of being. Instead, it is about reintroducing ourselves to ourself.
I want to be clear that these ideas are taken from Rohr and Wilber. In many ways, I am taking what they said and expounding on them from my own reflection and experience. I once thanked a mentor of mine for all the wisdom he sent my way and he simply said, "I'm just sending the things I have learned downstream". Rohr and Wilber's work has done this for me. I want to keep sending what I am learning downstream so I'm not burying talents (parable reference) so to speak.
My wife forwarded an article by Jen Hatmaker regarding parenting especially of young children. I found it to be encouraging, normalizing, and authentic. Three things that all of us parents need. I think I most appreciated the sense of "me too". It has been said that when it comes to parenting we just need to be good enough and to know we are not alone. Here is the link to the article..."I Wish Someone Would've Warned Me About These BIG FEELINGS"
There is so much to be said, lived, and processed around pain and yet we rarely talk about it in our daily lives. Instead, we find that society invites us to avoid it through some invitation that subtly says, "this will bring you happiness" or "this will take away the pain". The reality is that true joy must be lived through the pain not away from it. The means that we must surrender or fall into it not from it. This is why Step 3 in the Twelve Step program is so powerful which says, "Made a Decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as I understood Him".
The paradox to our pain is in the surrendering to it. Life is found once we surrender to the struggle albeit emotional, physical, and mental. There is life on the other side though it cannot be known or understood until we grow through it. Richard Rohr writes is so well in a recent daily mediation that I have linked that he titled Luminous Darkness
or click here http://conta.cc/1qTCBdt
I am more and more convinced that healing must take place through the vehicle of relationship. I view relationship holistically from that standpoint of relationship with ourselves, with others, and with God. That being said, I find that the most growth happens in the context of community. A healing community doesn't just happen because people meet together. It happens when we feel safe. It happens when we know that what we say or do will be held within the group and we won't be judged, rejected, or corrected. It means that those in a group allow each of us "to be as we are" and to experience acceptance for our being. It requires an implicit knowledge of "being with". Meaning that you know because you know that others "feel" your pain. It is in the place of experiencing "being known" that we begin to be healed. When we are known by others, we experience the most fundamental and core needs that we matter, that we are understood, and that we can count on another to be there with us.
Group therapy invites us to start taking the risks of being known both currently and historically. Trust, security, and safety has to be earned by a group but not demanded. It is once you get a sense of that security that you can begin to open up. Group gently invites us to be authentic by seeing others authenticity. I have heard it said that "vulnerability begets vulnerability". Our group motto is "come as you are, be as you are." Which means that there is no time table / pressure to this process other than showing up. The reality is that group is just a microcosm for a larger sense of community.
Parker Palmer says it well when he says:
"The Soul is like a wild animal -- tough, resilient, savvy, self-sufficient, and yet exceedingly shy. If we want to see a wild animal, the last thing we should do is to go crashing through the woods, shouting for the creature to come out. But if we are willing to walk quietly into the woods and sit silently for an hour or two at the base of a tree, the creature we are waiting for may well emerge, and out of the corner of an eye we will catch a glimpse of the precious wildness we seek." ~ quoted from Let Your Life Speak.
As a child, you are less concerned with the future and are able to just enjoy that very moment. A child in many ways, "doesn't have a worry in the world" other than what he or she is doing right then. Children live with their emotions on their sleeve and have the ability to be fully present. They serve as a reminder to be present.
Honestly, this is really hard for me. My default is to start thinking about the future which causes me to have anxiety, fear, and can turn into control. So the first step is to just notice; where you are, what you are doing, and what you are feeling. That will then usually bring up other other emotions such as fear, anxiety, etc. If that happens, let it run its course and call somebody. Call a friend and tell them exactly what is happening. Children do this much better than we do. Watch what a child does next time a tornado warning is given. They will be afraid and will let you know but they draw near to you. That is how we are made. We need others and we need the ability to draw near to somebody else. The greatest damage we can do to our soul is when we try to do it alone.
Children bring so many gifts and one of the gifts they bring is to help us see life through the lens of a child. It is through this lens we see joy, honesty, and hope.
I recently came across this poem and it resonated with me regarding each of our stories. I believe that so much of the therapeutic process is learning to find the words that connect us with our past and present. It is in finding these words that we grieve in a new way. A new way that helps us reorganize our pain. The poem is titled "The World Seems" by Gregory Orr. The link to his poem is below.
I am constantly recommending the following link to clients regarding shame and vulnerability. Brene Brown explains through her research on shame what exactly shame is and the way to live through it, with it, and how to use it. Here is the link...
Grief is all too often limited to pain, tears, and suffering. This is certainly a part of grief but it doesn't have to be all of it. A great exercise is to think back to a time in your life when you have had intense grief? What memory comes up? Were you alone? Did you feel better afterwards? More often than not, the memory is negative because we were alone and did not feel better.
We often want to avoid grief because of our previous grief experience. Our resistance has some validity to it. It tells us something about our story. If your grief memory was of you being alone then certainly why would you want to go back to a lonely and grief filled place.
The hope is that we can all enter into a phrase of grief that does not equal suffering. Rather it equals a reorganizing joy. Grief and joy can coexist! I have often sat with people who have and are going through recovery where they describe a profound sense of joy in the grief. That is why so many people say that the emotion of sadness is the healing feeling. Recovery of one's heart allows us to feel joy for the first time instead of grief. For so many, tears were a dead end and lonely street. So for many, you stopped crying because it didn't help. For others, it just led to more despair.
John Bowlby and Colin Murray Parkes, pioneers in attachment theory, broke down grief into 4 phases: (1) Shock and Numbness, (2) Yearning and Searching, (3) Despair and Disorganization, (4) Reorganization and Recovery.
There is a treasure at the end of the rainbow. Our story is longing to be seen, told, and grieved in new ways. If you find yourself acting in the same old pattern then take a gracious look at your story. Our negative reactions and behaviors really are unresolved trauma and grief. The invitation is to start thinking and talking about those events of pain so that you can grieve them in a new deeper way, a fresh clean way. These tears lead us to wholeness and joy not despair. We all need help in reorganizing and making sense of our grief otherwise it stays stuck. The beauty is a not only a shared storied but a shared experience. Our stories are too valuable for grief to be shared by ourselves.
If you are like me, I am so prone to only wanting pleasantries in relationships. My default is to take the positive but shy away, defend, or run from the negative aspects of relationship. The problem with this style is that its really not a dynamic relationship. It is a relationship but it is impaired. It is not fluid and clean. The goal for any relationship is that we can go to those closest to us in both positive and negative ways where they are not only impacted by us but can help filter and embrace us in our pain. Thereby helping sooth our pain. We need this type of relationship and it is when we can't have this that the relationship really starts to suffer.
The truth is that we impact each other in relationship. There is always going to be some positive and negative mixed in. It is just the nature of it. We are made to be impacted by each other so that we can respond not react. The challenge for so many of us is that if our story was one of reacting to our emotions not responding then it is impossible not to continue on in that same pattern. This is where we need our own healing. All of us need to be responded to but not reacted to. A safe relationship is one where you can "be you" responding to your true self not your false self and vise versa.
I have found that one of the best groups and resources is found in the Adult Children of Alcoholics (ACA) communities.
When you hear the word emotion what comes to mind? For me, I used to think of emotion as predominately something to avoid such as sadness, anger, and especially fear. I definitely did everything to avoid fear. I also thought our emotions were not something to give too much weight to because it would dictate what I felt like doing. Thereby, throwing out my ethics and morality. For example, 'I don't feel like taking care of my kids today so I will just go and play golf', etc. The reality and danger is by not recognizing and naming the emotion.
It is important to distinguish between the words "feeling" and "emotion". Emotion in Latin means to move and is a noun. Whereas, the word feeling is a verb and its root means to perceive. Feelings subjectively represent emotion. Emotions are initial / internal attitudes like mad, sad, fear, shame, etc. Feelings, on the other hand, are a product of the emotions and more a "state of being" like joyfulness or depression.
Emotions are necessary realities. We really cannot control them but we can regulate them.
Also, they are not the end all. Emotions are fluid so they come and go. These are the gateway to our soul. It illuminates our needs and vulnerabilities. It allows us to then be able to have empathy. Empathy is the gift. We have to have empathy in order to connect. Without empathy, we cannot have connectedness at the deep core level of our being.
The reality is that emotions are the musical notes but do not comprise of the whole dance. We need emotions because it gives us the ability to know how to dance and what step to take next. But we are not the only one's dancing. When we have emotion, we usually have it with somebody else. In fact, we need to have emotions with another person. That is how we are made. We are made to experience this together. We actually need another person to help us co-regulate our emotions. We were never designed to regulate our emotions by ourselves. Our human natures requires that we process emotions through co-regulation not self-regulation. A person with us, a parent, a spouse, a friend is what we need in order to help us breath. I have heard it said that connection is like oxygen. Well, the emotions can either hinder us or aid us in helping us breath this oxygen. With life's tragedies and struggles we need others to help us breath!
Some great books that further clarifies and explains this is Dr. Sue Johnson's book "Hold Me Tight" or "The Circle of Security Intervention" by Powell, Cooper, Hoffman, and Marvin.